Skip to main content
FREE U.S. SHIPPING $100+
Shop Now
Search (0)
Search
(0)
Rewards Need Help?

Gifts Under $500

filter
Sort by Reset
  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, new to old
Skip to pagination
Script Initial Circle
Script Initial Circle - ci3ver-SI - hover

Script Initial Circle

From$100.00
Gold
Gold
14k Gold 14k Gold Initial Circle
14k Gold Initial Circle - Ci4-14k-Y-i - hover

14k Gold Initial Circle

From$375.00
14k Yellow Gold
14k Yellow Gold
14k Gold 14k Gold Rounded Mini Dog Tag
14k Gold Rounded Mini Dog Tag - RND-DT-14K-Y-CHM - hover

14k Gold Rounded Mini Dog Tag

From$350.00
14k Yellow Gold
14k Yellow Gold
Pavé Large Dog Tag Necklace
Pavé Large Dog Tag Necklace - PVE-LRG-DT-SS-NCK - hover

Pavé Large Dog Tag Necklace

From$275.00
Silver
Silver
'GYPB' Flamingo Circle Tag by Lindsey Gurk
'GYPB' Flamingo Circle Tag by Lindsey Gurk - ci1-GYPB-CHM-ss - hover

'GYPB' Flamingo Circle Tag by Lindsey Gurk

From$95.00
Sterling Silver
Sterling Silver
Circle Pendant Necklace - Custom Phrase or Quote
Circle Pendant Necklace - Custom Phrase or Quote - cpc1-ver - hover

Circle Pendant Necklace - Custom Phrase or Quote

From$160.00
Gold
Gold
Engravable Cross Necklace
Engravable Cross Necklace - Ci1-VER-crss - hover

Engravable Cross Necklace

From$100.00
Gold
Gold
Circle Initial Necklace Set
Circle Initial Necklace Set - 2-ci4-ci1-nck-set-ver - hover

Circle Initial Necklace Set

From$145.00
Gold
Gold
ready to ship Circle Pendant Necklace - Grandma, Mother, Love
Circle Pendant Necklace - Grandma, Mother, Love - cp3vergml - hover

Circle Pendant Necklace - Grandma, Mother, Love

From$140.00
Gold
Gold
Circle & Heart Necklace
Circle & Heart Necklace - 2cihe-ver-ci1 - hover

Circle & Heart Necklace

From$200.00
Gold
Gold
ready to ship The Perfect Bundle with Gold 'mama' Bracelet - 10P-NPMB-VER - main
The Perfect Bundle with Gold 'mama' Bracelet - 10P-NPMB-VER - hover

The Perfect Bundle with Gold 'mama' Bracelet

$135.00
ready to ship Sterling Silver Pavé Vertical Mama Necklace - MN-PCZ-MA-SS - main
Sterling Silver Pavé Vertical Mama Necklace - MN-PCZ-MA-SS - hover

Sterling Silver Pavé Vertical Mama Necklace

$210.00
Sale
14k Gold 14k Gold Aries Choker - ari-ch-14k - main
14k Gold Aries Choker - ari-ch-14k - hover

14k Gold Aries Choker

$260.00$200.00
ready to ship Gold Pavé Vertical Love Necklace - MN-PCZ-LV-VER - main
Gold Pavé Vertical Love Necklace - MN-PCZ-LV-VER - hover

Gold Pavé Vertical Love Necklace

$230.00
Engravable Rainbow Necklace
Engravable Rainbow Necklace - Ci1-VER-Rain - hover

Engravable Rainbow Necklace

From$100.00
Gold
Gold
14k Gold 14k Gold Mini Story Charm
14k Gold Mini Story Charm - Ci4-14k-Y-ADOP - hover

14k Gold Mini Story Charm

$355.00
14k Yellow Gold
14k Yellow Gold
ready to ship 14k Gold Pavé Diamond Cross Stud Earrings
14k Gold Pavé Diamond Cross Stud Earrings - PV-DI-CRS-2ST-14Y - hover

14k Gold Pavé Diamond Cross Stud Earrings

From$235.00
14k Yellow Gold
14k Yellow Gold
ready to ship Gold Mini Dog Tag Mama Necklace - DT-VER-F1-mama - main
Gold Mini Dog Tag Mama Necklace - DT-VER-F1-mama - hover

Gold Mini Dog Tag Mama Necklace

$130.00
14k Gold 14k Gold Engravable Breast Cancer Ribbon Circle Tag - Ci1-14k-Y-Prib - main
14k Gold Engravable Breast Cancer Ribbon Circle Tag - Ci1-14k-Y-Prib - hover

14k Gold Engravable Breast Cancer Ribbon Circle Tag

$380.00
ready to ship Sterling Silver Pavé Vertical Love Necklace - MN-PCZ-LV-SS - main
Sterling Silver Pavé Vertical Love Necklace - MN-PCZ-LV-SS - hover

Sterling Silver Pavé Vertical Love Necklace

$210.00
ready to ship Star of David Charm
Star of David Charm - SS-SOD-MIN-CHM - hover

Star of David Charm

From$95.00
Silver
Silver
ready to ship Reflection Coin Pendant Necklace
Reflection Coin Pendant Necklace - RCP-VER-PCC-18 - hover

Reflection Coin Pendant Necklace

From$235.00
Gold
Gold
Script Warrior Nameplate Necklace
Script Warrior Nameplate Necklace - NPWVER-14/16 - hover

Script Warrior Nameplate Necklace

From$120.00
Gold
Gold
Birthstone Necklace Mommy & Me Set
Birthstone Necklace Mommy & Me Set - 2BS-NCK-SET-VER - hover

Birthstone Necklace Mommy & Me Set

From$145.00
Gold
Gold
Fierce Script Nameplate Necklace
Fierce Script Nameplate Necklace - NPF-VER - hover

Fierce Script Nameplate Necklace

From$120.00
Gold
Gold
ready to ship Butterfly Necklace
Butterfly Necklace - BTRFLY-NCK-SS - hover

Butterfly Necklace

From$95.00
Sterling Silver
Sterling Silver
Circle & Mini Dog Tag Necklace with Birthstones
Circle & Mini Dog Tag Necklace with Birthstones - 2cidt-ver00-ci1 - hover

Circle & Mini Dog Tag Necklace with Birthstones

From$255.00
Gold
Gold
Circle & Heart Necklace with Birthstones
Circle & Heart Necklace with Birthstones - 2ci1he-ver - hover

Circle & Heart Necklace with Birthstones

From$260.00
Gold
Gold
14k Gold 14k Gold Round Mini Locket Charm
14k Gold Round Mini Locket Charm - RND-MIN-LCKT-CHM-14K-Y - hover

14k Gold Round Mini Locket Charm

$425.00
14k Yellow Gold
14k Yellow Gold
ready to ship Pavé Star of David Necklace
Pavé Star of David Necklace - SS-PCZ-SOD-MIN-NCK - hover

Pavé Star of David Necklace

From$160.00
Silver
Silver
ready to ship 14k Gold Cross Stud Earrings
14k Gold Cross Stud Earrings - SLD-CRS-2ST-14W - hover

14k Gold Cross Stud Earrings

From$138.00
14k White Gold
14k White Gold
14k Gold 14k Gold Heart Mini Locket Charm
14k Gold Heart Mini Locket Charm - HRT-MIN-LCKT-CHM-14K-Y - hover

14k Gold Heart Mini Locket Charm

$425.00
14k Yellow Gold
14k Yellow Gold
Engravable Adoption Necklace
Engravable Adoption Necklace - Ci1-VER-Adop - hover

Engravable Adoption Necklace

From$100.00
Gold
Gold
Pavé Large Dog Tag
Pavé Large Dog Tag - PVE-LRG-DT-SS-CHM - hover

Pavé Large Dog Tag

From$250.00
Silver
Silver
top gift Notched Initial Pendant Necklace
Notched Initial Pendant Necklace - NiPN-SS - hover

Notched Initial Pendant Necklace

From$295.00
sterling silver
sterling silver
New
Pave Pendant Necklace
Pave Pendant Necklace - PaPN-VER - hover

Pave Pendant Necklace

From$270.00
Gold
Gold
New
Notched Pendant Necklace
Notched Pendant Necklace - NPN-VER - hover

Notched Pendant Necklace

From$295.00
Gold
Gold
14k Gold 14k Gold Script Initial Circle
14k Gold Script Initial Circle - CI3-14k-Y-SI - hover

14k Gold Script Initial Circle

$415.00
14k Yellow Gold
14k Yellow Gold
Engravable Breast Cancer Ribbon Necklace
Engravable Breast Cancer Ribbon Necklace - Ci1-VER-Prib - hover

Engravable Breast Cancer Ribbon Necklace

From$100.00
Gold
Gold
ready to ship Mama Nameplate + Pavé Heart Earrings Set
Mama Nameplate + Pavé Heart Earrings Set - MNP-14/16-HRT-STD-SET-SS - hover

Mama Nameplate + Pavé Heart Earrings Set

From$195.00
Sterling Silver
Sterling Silver
ready to ship Heart Ring + Heart Earrings Set
Heart Ring + Heart Earrings Set - HRT-BND/EAR-SET-5.5-SS - hover

Heart Ring + Heart Earrings Set

From$145.00
Sterling Silver
Sterling Silver
Pavé Monogram Large Dog Tag
Pavé Monogram Large Dog Tag - PVE-LRG-MONO-DT-SS-CHM - hover

Pavé Monogram Large Dog Tag

From$250.00
Silver
Silver
ready to ship Star of David Necklace
Star of David Necklace - SS-SOD-MIN-NCK - hover

Star of David Necklace

From$115.00
Silver
Silver
ready to ship 14k Gold Pavé Diamond Heart Stud Earrings
14k Gold Pavé Diamond Heart Stud Earrings - PV-DI-HRT-2ST-14Y - hover

14k Gold Pavé Diamond Heart Stud Earrings

From$235.00
14k Yellow Gold
14k Yellow Gold
Gold Script Initial Circle - ci3ver0S - main
Gold Script Initial Circle - ci3ver0S - hover

Gold Script Initial Circle

From$115.00
14k Gold 14k Gold Engravable Adoption Symbol - Ci1-14k-Y-Adop - main
14k Gold Engravable Adoption Symbol - Ci1-14k-Y-Adop - hover

14k Gold Engravable Adoption Symbol

$380.00
Gold Mini Dog Charms & Heart - tinytags
Gold Mini Dog Tags & Heart Necklace - 3dthedt-ver - hover

Gold Mini Dog Tags & Heart Necklace

From$325.00
New
Pave Monogram Pendant Necklace
Pave Monogram Pendant Necklace - PaPN-I-SS - hover

Pave Monogram Pendant Necklace

From$270.00
Sterling Silver
Sterling Silver
2 ... 3 4 5

Jewelry Gifts Under $500

Discover the perfect gift at a perfect price with our Gifts Under $500. These curated pieces offer luxury and style without the hefty price tag. Whether for anniversaries, graduations, or milestones, find the ideal gift that fits your budget.

2025 Tiny Tags

Your Bag is Empty

Start Shopping!

square and oval personalized locket necklaces by tiny tags

New Arrivals
woman holding tiny tags mini dog tag necklace in hands wearing other jewelry

Best Sellers

husband and wife embracing with wife wearing tiny tags necklaces

Gifts For Wife

skinny bar necklace by tiny tags engraved with three names

Gifts for Mom

“I’m so in love with my tiny tags necklace, and the customer service at tiny tags is also so incredible! I needed assistance more than once, and they went above and beyond every time for me! xo”

Mariah Z.

"Beautiful, I love it, it has meaning, very classy and will be a staple item in my jewelry collection."

Jacqueline M.

"I will never take this necklace off. Three boys and along came a girl! Yes, I bought this for myself. A present for me! Thank you- I love it!"

Lisa B.

Shop Best Sellers
Thanks for contacting us! We'll get back to you as soon as possible. Thanks for subscribing Thanks! We will notify you when it becomes available! The max number of items have already been added There is only one item left to add to the cart There are only [num_items] items left to add to the cart